Axel's take: 8.2/10
Spacious downtown suites with historic character, but street construction complicates the stay. a 3-star extended-stay hotel in a historic downtown bank, scored for what it is.
This 3-star extended-stay hotel puts practical apartment-style suites inside the historic Buckeye Bank Building. It's a strong pick for travelers who want a kitchen, room to spread out and a walkable downtown base rather than luxury extras. Tripadvisor and Expedia guests repeatedly praise helpful staff and clean, comfortable rooms; included breakfast and Buckeye Bourbon House add convenience. A hotel representative reports that the renovation is complete, so earlier construction-era complaints need that context.
The bigger current drawback is Capital Line construction on Gay Street: roadwork and changing access arrangements remain an issue in October 2026. On-site parking is paid valet only, and some guests mention street or alley noise. We'd choose it for longer stays and downtown business trips, but skip it if quiet surroundings and straightforward car access are priorities.
-
Best for: longer downtown stays; families wanting kitchens and extra space; business travelers
-
Watch out for: Capital Line roadwork and changing access; paid valet-only parking on-site; possible street or alley noise
-
Location: Walkable downtown base near theaters and restaurants; Gay Street construction complicates access.
-
Rooms: Apartment-style suites with full kitchens; guests praise space and comfort, with some exterior-noise reports.
-
Cleanliness: Generally a strength across recent Expedia and Tripadvisor feedback.
-
Service: Repeated praise for helpful front-desk and valet staff, though experiences are not uniformly positive.
-
Amenities: Included hot breakfast, Buckeye Bourbon House and guest laundry; breakfast feedback varies.
-
Fees and surprises: Paid valet with no on-site self-parking; nonrefundable pet fee; housekeeping every other day.
Axel's opinion of Residence Inn by Marriott Columbus Downtown, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Expedia · Booking.com · linkedin.com · downtowncolumbus.com. Reviewed Oct 15, 2026.