Axel's take: 8.2/10
A strong pool-first pick, but not for quiet nights or walking to Duval. A Cuban-themed 4-star pool resort in Key West’s New Town, scored for what it is.
Havana Cabana is a Cuban-themed 4-star resort in New Town, strongest as a sociable poolside base rather than a luxury retreat. We'd pick it for the large landscaped pool, tiki bar and friendly service. Recent Tripadvisor and Trip.com guests repeatedly praise clean rooms, helpful staff and the Old Town shuttle, which makes the outlying location workable. The colorful styling gives it more personality than a standard chain hotel.
The trade-offs are real: rooms and bathrooms don't consistently match the resort setting, poolside music can intrude, and mandatory resort and destination fees deserve attention. September 2026 guests reported construction noise; management says no construction is happening on-site, so check nearby work before booking. It also welcomes children, despite older adults-only descriptions. We'd skip it for guaranteed quiet, polished luxury or doorstep access to Duval Street.
-
Best for: couples and friends who enjoy a lively pool; families planning downtime at the hotel; drivers happy to use the Old Town shuttle
-
Watch out for: poolside music and reported nearby work noise; mandatory resort and destination fees; not walkable to Duval’s main attractions
-
Location: New Town boulevard setting; the included shuttle is the practical connection to Old Town.
-
Rooms: Colorful and generally comfortable, with some dated bathrooms and uneven maintenance reports.
-
Cleanliness: Strong praise across recent Tripadvisor and Trip.com reviews outweighs scattered complaints.
-
Service: Friendly staff and informative shuttle drivers are recurring strengths.
-
Amenities: Large pool, hot tub, tiki bar and Cuban food truck; fitness-center access is off-site.
-
Fees and surprises: Mandatory resort and destination fees; parking and shuttle included, breakfast generally extra, and children welcome.
Axel's opinion of Havana Cabana at Key West, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Trip.com · Expedia. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.