The Caledonian Edinburgh rates, Edinburgh

Check your stay

Choose the matching dates and guests, or use the current-price link above for another stay.

Axel's take: 8.2/10

Grand Edinburgh character and warm service, tempered by ongoing construction. a historic five-star railway hotel on Princes Street, scored for what it is.

The Caledonian is a historic five-star railway hotel at the west end of Princes Street, now under Hilton’s Curio Collection rather than Waldorf Astoria. It’s a strong pick for sightseeing with traditional grandeur: castle-view rooms, handsome public spaces and an indoor pool give it genuine appeal. Tripadvisor and Expedia guests repeatedly praise welcoming staff, comfortable beds and breakfast, while cleanliness scores remain strong across booking sites.

The main reservation is the ongoing hotel expansion. Recent guests report daytime construction noise and rooms overlooking workers, and management confirms the works. Ask specifically about your room’s exposure before booking. Room sizes also vary considerably; a castle view doesn’t guarantee generous space. We’d choose it for a characterful city break, but skip it for a quiet daytime retreat or uniformly spacious luxury.

• Best for: sightseers who like historic hotels; couples booking castle-view rooms; families wanting a central pool

• Watch out for: ongoing expansion and daytime construction noise; room sizes vary considerably; restricted swimming hours for younger children

• Location: West end of Princes Street, well placed for shopping, gardens and exploring central Edinburgh.

• Rooms: Comfortable beds and appealing castle-view options; confirm size and construction exposure.

• Cleanliness: Strong overall ratings and repeated praise for housekeeping outweigh isolated lapses.

• Service: Warm, helpful staff are a consistent strength, though complaint handling can be uneven.

• Amenities: Indoor pool, whirlpool, sauna, steam room and gym; children aged 11 and under have designated swimming hours.

• Fees and surprises: Breakfast is not included in every booking; nearby parking and pets cost extra, and expansion works remain a concern.

Axel's opinion of The Caledonian Edinburgh, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Expedia · Booking.com · scottishconstructionnow.com. Reviewed Oct 20, 2026.

About The Caledonian Edinburgh

• 5-star hotel
• Waldorf Astoria Hotels & Resorts
• Princes Street, Edinburgh
• Amenities: Air conditioning, Elevator/lift, Currency exchange, Smoke-free property, Heating, Security guard, Newspapers, Ticket assistance, Express check-in/check-out, Television in lobby, Fire Extinguisher, Reception desk
• City page: Hotels in Edinburgh

More hotels in Edinburgh

• Hotels in Edinburgh
• Regent House Hotel
• Ten Hill Place
• Hotel Roomzzz Edinburgh
• 24 Royal Terrace
• 28 York Place
• a&o Edinburgh City - Hostel
• Aparthotel Adagio Edinburgh Royal Mile
• Apex Waterloo Place Hotel
• Cairn Hotel
• Courtyard by Marriott Edinburgh
• Edinburgh House Hotel
• Fingal - A Luxury Floating Hotel
• Hotels by destination