Axel's take on Times Square & Theater District: #2 of 12 in New York, 7.7/10
Stay for Broadway and convenience, not peace or neighborhood charm. Broadway, abundant doorstep attractions and useful connections outweigh modest hotel value and a crowded setting that sacrifices neighborhood calm.
Stay here when Broadway is a main event, not an optional evening. The theaters, illuminated plazas and Restaurant Row on West 46th Street make dinner-and-a-show nights straightforward. Bryant Park and Rockefeller Center are easy walks, and the concentration of subway connections makes changing plans painless.
The compromise is the pavement outside: crowds, advertising and people selling experiences follow you home. Recent visitors disagree about whether that feels exciting or exhausting, rather than about its convenience. Choose a side street over Broadway itself if possible. Skip it if your ideal New York evening means wandering relaxed residential blocks after dinner.
- Best for: first-time visitors, museums and culture, travelers without a car
- Skip it if: Crowds wear you out; You want quiet evenings
- Getting around: 1/2/3/7/N/Q/R/W/S at Times Square and A/C/E at Eighth Avenue; walk to Broadway and Bryant Park; JFK via E–AirTrain, LGA via 7–Q70, EWR via Penn–NJ Transit–airport transfer; no one-seat airport-terminal trains.
- After dark: Bright and crowded into the evening, with another rush when theaters empty; light sleepers should prioritize room position.
- Rates: Typical Axel rate $472 a night · usually 8% under the public rate
Where to stay in New York: every neighborhood ranked
The best hotels in Times Square & Theater District, ranked by Axel's take
Each hotel scored for what it is by Axel's own review; the rate is one stay Axel priced this week, beside the public rate for the same dates.
- Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York 8.9/10, ultra-luxury five-star hotel in Midtown Manhattan. Baccarat delivers Midtown glamour, with occasional service lapses keeping it short of flawless. $1,850 a night with Axel; no public rate was seen for these dates. Sign up free to book this rate
- Hotel Riu Plaza New York Times Square 8.6/10, busy, modern 4-star near Broadway and Times Square. A dependable Broadway base with excellent breakfast, but expect crowds rather than calm. $424 a night with Axel; no public rate was seen for these dates. Sign up free to book this rate
- New York Marriott Marquis 8.5/10, huge upscale convention hotel in the heart of Times Square. A strong Broadway base with roomy accommodations, but little escape from big-hotel bustle. $487 a night with Axel; no public rate was seen for these dates. Sign up free to book this rate
- Hotel St. James 8.0/10, no-frills budget hotel in a historic building near Times Square. A strong Broadway base if location matters more than modern rooms and extras. $376 a night with Axel against $418 a night on Expedia for the same dates and party: $42 a night less (10%). Sign up free to book this rate
- The Belvedere Hotel 7.9/10, historic, no-frills mid-range hotel near Broadway. A practical Broadway base with roomy accommodations, but aging interiors and elevator bottlenecks. $511 a night with Axel against $789 a night on Expedia for the same dates and party: $278 a night less (35%). Sign up free to book this rate
- New York Hilton Midtown 7.4/10, large 4-star convention hotel in Midtown Manhattan. A practical Midtown base, but dated rooms and elevator works temper the appeal. $460 a night with Axel; no public rate was seen for these dates. Sign up free to book this rate
- Sheraton New York Times Square Hotel 6.8/10, large 4-star convention hotel in Midtown Manhattan. The location delivers, but tired rooms and uneven service weaken the four-star promise. $349 a night with Axel; no public rate was seen for these dates. Sign up free to book this rate
- OYO Times Square 6.3/10, basic Midtown hotel with a four-star listing. Choose it for Broadway convenience, not four-star comfort. $317 a night with Axel against $362 a night on Expedia for the same dates and party: $45 a night less (12%). Sign up free to book this rate
- The Gallivant Times Square 6.2/10, basic, older independent hotel in the Theater District. A handy Broadway base, but room quality and extra charges make it a compromise. $193 a night with Axel against $268 a night on Expedia for the same dates and party: $75 a night less (28%). Sign up free to book this rate