Axel's take: 8.9/10
Historic character and thoughtful service make this a strong alternative to downtown chains. a historic 3-star boutique hotel in a former monastery, scored for what it is.
The Priory is a 42-room, 3-star boutique hotel in a former Benedictine monastery, and we'd pick it for character, personal service and useful extras. Tripadvisor and Expedia guests consistently praise clean, comfortable rooms and genuinely helpful staff. The garden courtyard and tiny Monks’ Bar give it personality, while included parking and breakfast make it good value. Management says renovations throughout the hotel finished in 2025.
The main compromise is the Deutschtown setting: convenient for North Side attractions, but not a busy downtown restaurant district, and some recent guests feel uncomfortable walking nearby after dark. Breakfast is preordered and boxed, rather than a full buffet. Confirm shuttle hours instead of assuming all-day service. We'd skip it if doorstep nightlife or a conventional full-service hotel matters more than historic charm.
-
Best for: couples who like historic hotels; baseball and museum weekends; drivers wanting included parking
-
Watch out for: some guests feel uneasy walking nearby after dark; boxed breakfast with limited dietary choices; confirm shuttle operating hours
-
Location: Deutschtown base near North Side attractions; immediate dining options and nighttime walking appeal divide guests.
-
Rooms: Traditional decor and comfortable beds; standard rooms have one bed, so check layouts for groups.
-
Cleanliness: Strong praise across guest-review sites outweighs isolated complaints about mustiness.
-
Service: Friendly, accommodating reception staff, bartenders and shuttle drivers are a consistent strength.
-
Amenities: Garden courtyard, 14-seat bar, fitness room and included breakfast; accessible rooms lack roll-in showers.
-
Fees and surprises: Parking and breakfast are included; EV charging costs extra, and weddings can restrict courtyard access.
Axel's opinion of The Priory Hotel, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Expedia · Booking.com. Reviewed Oct 15, 2026.