Axel's take: 7.8/10
Creekside balconies and welcoming staff outweigh dated finishes, but check elevator access. An older, budget-friendly 3-star creekside lodge near downtown Gatlinburg, scored for what it is.
Brookside Lodge is an older, budget-friendly 3-star with a quieter creekside setting than Gatlinburg’s main strip. It’s a good pick for travelers who value spacious rooms, outdoor space and friendly service over polished interiors. Tripadvisor and Expedia guests repeatedly praise the balconies overlooking Roaring Fork Creek and helpful staff. Downtown is roughly a 15-minute walk away, with a trolley stop outside; two seasonal outdoor pools and included breakfast add family appeal.
The hotel says its renovation finished in 2022, but recent guests still describe worn bathrooms and uneven upkeep. Cleanliness feedback is mostly positive, though not uniform, and breakfast opinions vary. Multiple September 2026 Expedia guests reported a broken elevator: confirm repairs or request a ground-floor room if stairs are difficult. Expedia also lists paid parking. We’d skip it for sleek rooms or dependable step-free access.
-
Best for: Budget-conscious families; Couples wanting a creekside balcony; Smokies visitors comfortable with a downtown walk
-
Watch out for: Recent elevator outages; confirm repairs; Dated bathrooms and uneven upkeep; Parking charge listed by Expedia
-
Location: Quieter East Parkway setting beside Roaring Fork Creek, roughly 15 minutes from downtown on foot.
-
Rooms: Generally spacious, with creek-facing balconies or patios; rustic furnishings and some worn finishes.
-
Cleanliness: Mostly praised in recent Expedia reviews, with some contrasting reports on Tripadvisor.
-
Service: Friendly, helpful staff are a consistent strength across recent reviews.
-
Amenities: Two seasonal outdoor pools, breakfast, fitness center, laundry and outdoor firepit; breakfast reviews vary.
-
Fees and surprises: Expedia lists paid parking; September 2026 guests reported elevator outages, so confirm access before booking.
Axel's opinion of Brookside Lodge, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Expedia · Tripadvisor · Booking.com. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.