Axel's take: 7.6/10
Choose it for downtown history and character, not seamless full-service comfort. A historic mid-range boutique hotel in downtown Buffalo, scored for what it is.
The Lafayette is a historic mid-range boutique hotel whose character is more convincing than its full-service polish. It's a good pick for exploring downtown Buffalo or walking to a game at Sahlen Field or KeyBank Center. Recent Expedia and Tripadvisor guests repeatedly praise clean rooms, helpful reception staff and the building's architectural charm. Suites offer more breathing room, while standard rooms can be compact. We'd choose it for a short city break rather than a pampering stay.
The trade-offs are uneven upkeep and limited dining convenience: recent guests describe worn edges and fixtures needing attention. Public Espresso closed on April 4, 2026; Soirée Lounge & Grill has opened, but Visit Buffalo lists lunch and dinner only Thursday through Saturday. Parking is free with the hotel's arrangement at Adams Ramp, one block away—not on-site. We'd skip it if dependable breakfast, easy luggage unloading or consistently polished rooms are priorities.
-
Best for: architecture and history enthusiasts; downtown sightseeing breaks; baseball and hockey visitors
-
Watch out for: uneven room maintenance; limited on-site dining hours; parking garage one block away
-
Location: Central downtown base near Metro Rail, Sahlen Field and major sightseeing stops.
-
Rooms: Distinctive layouts; suites can be spacious, standard rooms smaller, with some maintenance complaints.
-
Cleanliness: Recent Expedia and Tripadvisor reviews generally praise clean rooms; Booking.com's aggregate is less strong.
-
Service: Reception staff earn frequent praise, though problem handling and staff availability receive mixed feedback.
-
Amenities: Free Wi-Fi and a fitness center; Soirée offers limited-week dining, and Public Espresso has closed.
-
Fees and surprises: Free Adams Ramp parking requires the hotel arrangement; Booking.com lists a refundable credit-card damage deposit.
Axel's opinion of Hotel at the Lafayette Trademark Collection by Wyndham, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Expedia · Tripadvisor · Booking.com · audacy.com · visitbuffalo.com. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.