17John rates, New York

Check your stay

Choose the matching dates and guests, or use the current-price link above for another stay.

Axel's take: 7.4/10

Generous downtown apartments, but renovations and uneven upkeep make this a qualified pick. An upscale apartment hotel in Manhattan’s Financial District, scored for what it is.

17John is an upscale apartment hotel, not a conventional full-service four-star. Its strongest selling points are spacious studios and suites with equipped kitchens, Fulton Street subway access, and useful extras including a gym, laundry room and rooftop terrace. Booking.com and Expedia’s overall ratings are strong, with guests repeatedly praising the space, comfortable beds and downtown convenience. We’d consider it for a longer stay where cooking and spreading out matter more than hotel service.

The trade-offs deserve attention. Current property listings disclose lower-floor renovations, with potential weekday noise from 10am to 4pm; guests have also reported construction dust. Daily housekeeping costs extra, and check-in uses a keypad. Recent Tripadvisor reviews are substantially less positive than the larger booking-site samples, repeatedly raising cleanliness, maintenance and problem-handling concerns. We’d skip it for a quiet daytime workspace or if dependable four-star service is a priority.

• Best for: Longer stays with self-catering; Families wanting apartment-style space; Downtown visitors using the subway

• Watch out for: Lower-floor renovations and weekday daytime noise; Daily housekeeping costs extra; Uneven cleanliness, maintenance and problem handling

• Location: Steps from Fulton Street subway access, with Wall Street and the World Trade Center nearby.

• Rooms: Spacious studios and suites with equipped kitchens; comfortable beds draw praise, but street noise and maintenance complaints recur.

• Cleanliness: Strong Booking.com cleanliness ratings contrast with repeated recent Tripadvisor complaints and reports of construction dust.

• Service: Staff receive praise on booking sites, but recent reviews also describe keypad difficulties and poor issue resolution.

• Amenities: Gym, guest lounge, shared laundry, conference room and rooftop terrace; more apartment amenities than full-service hotel facilities.

• Fees and surprises: Daily cleaning is extra; no dedicated parking; check-in starts at 4pm; listings disclose ongoing lower-floor renovations.

Axel's opinion of 17John, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Booking.com · Expedia · Tripadvisor. Reviewed Oct 23, 2026.

About 17John

• Property type: Hotel
• 4-star hotel
• 17 John Street, New York
• Amenities: 24-hour reception, Smoke-free property, Express check-in/check-out, Garden, Television in lobby, Terrace, Fire Extinguisher, Laundry, Concierge services, Luggage storage, Restaurant, Bottled water
• Check-in from: 16:00:00
• Check-out by: 11:00:00
• City page: Hotels in New York

More hotels in New York

• Hotels in New York
• Aura Hotel Brooklyn
• The Gallivant Times Square
• Freehand New York
• Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn by IHG
• Madison LES Hotel
• OYO Times Square
• 42 Hotel
• Eurostars Wall Street
• Holiday Inn Brooklyn Downtown by IHG
• Holiday Inn New York City - Wall Street by IHG
• The Belvedere Hotel
• The Brooklyn
• Hotels by destination