Axel's take: 8.4/10
A strong family pick with welcoming staff, useful shuttles, and an out-of-town setting. A family-friendly mid-range resort across from Nantucket’s airport, scored for what it is.
Nantucket Inn is a family-friendly mid-range resort across from the airport, rather than a quaint downtown inn. It’s a strong pick if you want comfortable rooms and useful amenities without luxury-hotel expectations. Recent Expedia and Tripadvisor guests repeatedly praise cleanliness, helpful staff, and reliable complimentary shuttles. The heated indoor pool, tennis courts, and free bikes give families more to do than many smaller island inns.
The compromise is location: downtown outings require a shuttle, bike, or drive. Recent guests generally like the refreshed rooms, though some find them basic for the price. Breakfast costs extra, despite older reviews suggesting otherwise. The outdoor pool is seasonal; Expedia lists its season ending October 9. We’d skip it if walkable restaurants, harbor atmosphere, or polished luxury matter more than practical comforts.
-
Best for: families wanting pools and activities; travelers flying into Nantucket; guests comfortable using hotel shuttles
-
Watch out for: not walkable to downtown; breakfast costs extra; seasonal outdoor pool and beach shuttle
-
Location: Across from the airport; complimentary hourly downtown shuttle offsets the out-of-town setting.
-
Rooms: Mostly praised as comfortable and refreshed, but some guests find them basic for the price.
-
Cleanliness: A consistent strength in recent reviews, including daily housekeeping and well-kept pools.
-
Service: Friendly, helpful staff and dependable shuttle drivers attract repeated praise.
-
Amenities: Heated indoor pool, seasonal outdoor pool, hot tubs, tennis, gym, cafe, bar, and limited free bikes.
-
Fees and surprises: The hotel advertises no resort fee; parking is free, but breakfast is paid.
Axel's opinion of Nantucket Inn, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Booking.com · Expedia. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.