Axel's take: 7.2/10
Friendly staff and useful tram access, but room condition is the compromise. A traditional 3-star hotel in Edgbaston with gardens and unevenly updated rooms, scored for what it is.
The Plough & Harrow is a traditional 3-star in Edgbaston, with Victorian public rooms, gardens and a less central setting than Birmingham’s downtown hotels. It’s a good pick for travelers who value space and character over polished interiors. Tripadvisor, Expedia and Google guests repeatedly praise the welcoming staff, and breakfast earns plenty of positive mentions. The nearby Edgbaston Village tram makes city-center trips straightforward.
The compromise is consistency: recent guests describe both refreshed, clean bedrooms and tired rooms needing maintenance. Tripadvisor and Expedia reviews also report winter heating problems, so check that yours works promptly. There’s no lift, and the official room amenities list fans rather than air conditioning. Parking is free when booking direct but otherwise chargeable. We’d skip it if stairs, temperature control or reliably modern rooms are priorities.
-
Best for: short Birmingham breaks; business travelers using the tram; travelers who prefer traditional character
-
Watch out for: uneven room condition; winter heating complaints; no lift; confirm ground-floor access
-
Location: Edgbaston base with a nearby tram stop for Broad Street, the ICC and central Birmingham.
-
Rooms: Generous space for the class, but refurbishment and maintenance vary; air conditioning is not confirmed.
-
Cleanliness: Many guests praise clean rooms, although some report housekeeping lapses; not a uniformly poor pattern.
-
Service: Friendly, helpful staff are the clearest recurring strength across review sites.
-
Amenities: Gardens, terrace, lounges, bars, breakfast and free Wi-Fi; official room listings include fans.
-
Fees and surprises: Parking is free for direct bookings and otherwise chargeable; check whether breakfast is included.
Axel's opinion of Best Western Plough & Harrow Hotel, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Tripadvisor · Booking.com · Expedia · wanderlog.com. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.