Axel's take: 7.9/10
A cheerful, clean motel with useful extras, but contactless service takes some patience. A small, retro-styled roadside motel on Anastasia Island, scored for what it is.
The Local is a 20-room, retro-styled motel rather than a conventional full-service 3-star hotel. It's a good pick for a simple St. Augustine break: Tripadvisor and Expedia guests repeatedly praise the cleanliness, cheerful decor and convenient location. The outdoor pool, complimentary coffee room, in-room microwaves and fridges, and free parking give it more substance than looks alone. Downtown is roughly a mile away across the Bridge of Lions, with restaurants closer by.
The main compromise is the unstaffed front desk. Some guests find contactless arrival seamless; others report missing instructions, access problems or difficulty getting extra towels. Rooms can be compact, and bed comfort gets mixed feedback. We'd choose it for a short sightseeing or concert trip, but skip it if you want an onsite team, spacious rooms or a beachfront stay.
-
Best for: couples on short sightseeing breaks; St. Augustine Amphitheatre concertgoers; travelers who like independent retro motels
-
Watch out for: contactless check-in; no staffed front desk; compact rooms and mixed bed-comfort feedback; downtown requires a roughly mile-long walk
-
Location: Anastasia Island restaurants nearby; downtown across the bridge, not a beachfront location.
-
Rooms: Cheerful, simple rooms with microwaves and mini-fridges; smaller categories can feel tight.
-
Cleanliness: A consistent strength across recent guest reviews, though not every report is positive.
-
Service: Remote assistance earns praise, but arrival instructions and getting supplies can be uneven.
-
Amenities: Outdoor pool, complimentary coffee room and partner-gym access—not an onsite fitness center.
-
Fees and surprises: One parking space per room included; Expedia lists a damage deposit and pet and late-checkout fees.
Axel's opinion of The Local - St Augustine, from the hotel's website and recent guest reviews. Sources: Hotel website · Expedia · Tripadvisor · Booking.com. Reviewed Oct 10, 2026.